Will Sotomayor’s Retirement Decision Tilt the Supreme Court?


WASHINGTON, D.C. – Amid concerns over President Joe Biden’s waning popularity and the profound impact of Donald Trump’s three Supreme Court appointments, Democrats are confronting the potential for long-term judicial shifts. This sense of urgency has sparked discussions about Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor’s potential retirement. The thought process among some Democrats and left-leaning activists is rooted in fear that a reelection for Trump could dramatically alter the Supreme Court’s composition for decades to come.

🔊 Listen to this article below. 3 minutes and 38 seconds. 🔊

Justice Sotomayor, a stalwart of the Court’s liberal minority, was appointed 15 years ago and is nearing her 70th birthday. Despite living with Type 1 diabetes since childhood, her health appears stable, though she has voiced concerns about fatigue and her workload. The shadow of Justice Antonin Scalia’s death looms large for Democrats, who worry about leaving a vacancy for an opposition president to fill, potentially with Trump at the helm again. There’s a belief that if Sotomayor retires soon, Biden could ensure a smooth confirmation for her successor, thus preserving a liberal seat.

However, the feasibility of this strategy is complicated by two major obstacles: the stringent criteria of the left and the reluctance of the Senate. The left’s demands for a nominee who embodies identity politics and aligns closely with progressive values on key issues make finding a suitable candidate challenging. Such a nominee would likely face stiff opposition in the Senate, where even moderate Democrats and Republicans could balk at confirming a figure perceived as too ideologically extreme.

Illustration by The Atlantic. Source: J. Scott Applewhite / AP.

The difficulties of navigating these waters were illustrated by Biden’s attempt to appoint Adeel Mangi to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, a nomination that faced opposition due to Mangi’s alleged past affiliations and the Senate’s narrow Democratic majority. The prospect of securing Senate confirmation for a Supreme Court nominee, especially with the election looming, seems increasingly fraught. Key Democratic senators, particularly those in vulnerable positions or facing reelection, might view a controversial nominee as a political liability.

This dilemma underscores a broader issue within the Democratic Party: a tension between the drive for progressive ideals and the practical realities of governance. The push for Sotomayor’s early retirement, while motivated by a desire to safeguard the Court’s liberal faction, may reflect a misjudgment of the current political landscape. Biden’s presidency, already challenged by unpopularity and internal divisions, could be further jeopardized by moves that alienate the wider electorate.


Rather than seeking radical solutions, Democrats might need to reassess their strategic approach. The focus should perhaps shift from individual retirements to addressing the party’s ideological direction. Ensuring that the party’s actions resonate with a broader segment of the American public could be crucial for navigating the complexities of Supreme Court appointments and securing a favorable political future.

8 thoughts on “Will Sotomayor’s Retirement Decision Tilt the Supreme Court?

  1. Mathew Speer: “Justice Sotomayor, a stalwart of the Court’s liberal minority….”

    All nine “justices” are liberals, as have been the justices in every single “Supreme” Court since the inception of the biblically seditious Constitution as the law of the land – at least according to the only One with the authority to determine what constitutes conservatism.

    See blog article “Right, Left, and Center: Who Gets to Decide?” at bible versus constitution dot org. Search title on our Blog.

    For evidence that the Constitution is biblically seditious, see free online book “Bible Law vs. the United States Constitution: The Christian Perspective,” in which every Article and Amendment is examined by the Bible. Click on the top entry on our Online Books page.

    Find out how much you really know about the Constitution as compared to the Bible. Take our 10-question Constitution Survey in the sidebar and receive a free copy of the 85-page “Primer” of “BL vs. USC.”

    1. YOU are a liberal by the standards YOU claim to be biblical. You are also a HYPOCRITE. The Constitution is FAR MORE biblical than you have even been, and I have every reason to believe you KNOW that to be true.
      Note: Several years ago, I called you out for “quoting” HALF a sentence from the Bible in such a manner it appeared to say the EXACT OPPOSITE of what it actually said, and you FLAT OUT DENIED doing so. That alone proves you are either a LIAR or have no idea what your are saying. In both possible cases, you are the LAST person anyone should listen to.

      1. Cry more Cupcake. The fact that you still have a perpetual hard on for me is telling. I don’t even know who you are, nor do I care. I haven’t even been writing for several years. What a tool.

  2. Sodommeyer is lying about considering retirement. This is a Dem-Commie ploy to get the party pigs fired up to make sure that the “vote” turns out for whoever will be the actual POTUS candidate on the Dem-Commie ticket in November.

    1. If liberals believe she is considering retirement, they should be demanding she retire TODAY. That would allow the Democrat controlled Senate to confirm whoever Biden is told to nominate before the election CAN change who is in Washington.

  3. God forbid she retires while Bi-DUMB is still in office, and he replaces her with another incompetent, ignorant-of-the-law-and-Constitution Leftist, racist LOON like Ketanji-Brown!

    1. Ignorant would be better. What we have now involves people that actually know, but actively oppose, the Constitution.

  4. She should have never been she has broke her oath she has lied she has forced illegal laws, has not held up Our Constitution as Written, she is not fit to be in anything to do with this country, to be a justice you better believe in Our Constitution as Written, all Freedoms, Rights, if found out not to be should be automatically fired prosecuted, that includes all public, government, judiciary, teachers jobs, No Exceptions, state as well as federal, military

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *